When Franchisees Unite: What Franchisors Need To Know About Franchisee Associations

On Behalf of | Nov 20, 2026 | Firm News

Meeting Hall

A successful franchise system depends on a productive relationship between franchisors and franchisees. But disagreements over royalties, marketing expenditures, technology requirements, approved suppliers, operating costs, franchisor support and systemwide changes can strain even the strongest franchise relationships.

When concerns extend across multiple locations, franchisees may organize by forming independent franchisee associations or participating in informal groups to communicate shared concerns to the franchisor. These associations can provide valuable opportunities for dialogue and systemwide improvement, but they can also present significant legal and business considerations.

For franchisors, the challenge is balancing franchisees’ rights to organize and raise collective concerns with the franchisor’s legitimate authority to enforce contractual obligations, protect brand standards, and manage the franchise system. Several considerations should guide how franchisors approach franchisee associations.

1. Understand the Purpose and Activities of Franchisee Associations

Franchisee associations vary considerably in their purpose, structure, and level of independence. Some function primarily as advisory groups intended to facilitate communication with the franchisor, while others independently advocate for policy changes, challenge franchisor decisions, or coordinate responses to perceived systemwide problems.

Understanding an association’s objectives and the concerns driving its activities is an important first step. For example, is the association seeking clarification of a new operating requirement, questioning marketing expenditures, proposing alternative suppliers, or opposing a systemwide initiative?

The nature of the association’s activities matters. Constructive feedback may help a franchisor identify operational challenges and strengthen franchisee relationships. Coordinated refusals to comply with contractual obligations, however, may present separate legal and business concerns. 

When addressing a franchisee association, franchisors should focus on the issues being raised and the conduct involved, rather than attempting to identify association members. Seeking membership lists or questioning individual franchisees about their participation may create unnecessary legal exposure, particularly in jurisdictions that expressly protect franchisees’ rights to associate. 

2. Review Contractual Rights and Obligations

When franchisees collectively raise concerns, franchisors should review the applicable franchise agreements, operations manuals, and system policies before responding. This review can help clarify the contractual framework governing the issues at hand, the franchisor’s authority to address them, and any limitations on that authority.

The analysis will depend on the issues involved. Supplier disputes may implicate purchasing requirements and the franchisor’s authority to designate approved suppliers. Objections to technology platforms or new operating standards may require examining the franchisor’s authority to implement systemwide changes, applicable notice requirements, and franchisee obligations. Concerns about marketing expenditures or support services should be evaluated against the franchisor’s contractual obligations and any restrictions on the use of funds.

Importantly, broad contractual discretion does not necessarily resolve every question concerning how a particular policy or systemwide change may be implemented. The agreement’s language, applicable system policies, and governing law must be considered together. 

3. Recognize Statutory Protections for Franchisee Associations

One of the most important considerations for franchisors is that franchisees may have statutory protections when forming, joining, or participating in franchisee associations. Franchisors should not assume that franchisees lack legal protections simply because they are independent business owners rather than employees.

Several states, including Arkansas, California, Connecticut, Hawaii, Illinois, Iowa, Maryland, Michigan, Minnesota, Nebraska, New Jersey, Rhode Island, and Washington, have enacted franchise relationship laws that expressly address franchisees’ rights to associate. These laws may prohibit franchisors from restricting, discouraging, or interfering with association activities or retaliating against franchisees for participating in them. The scope of protection varies by jurisdiction. For example, Arkansas, Connecticut, Minnesota, Nebraska, and New Jersey broadly protect franchisees’ rights of free association for lawful purposes, while Iowa and Rhode Island specifically prohibit retaliation against franchisees for association participation.

The distinction between legitimate contractual enforcement and retaliation for protected association activity is particularly important. A franchisor may have valid grounds to address independently established contractual violations or operational deficiencies. However, adverse action taken against a franchisee in the context of association activity may invite allegations of interference or retaliation.

Franchisors should consult experienced franchise counsel when an association forms or begins raising concerns, particularly before taking action that could affect participating franchisees. Counsel can help evaluate applicable state protections, assess potential antitrust considerations, and distinguish protected association activity from conduct that may independently warrant a contractual response. Early legal guidance can also help franchisors prevent communications or decisions that unnecessarily escalate an otherwise manageable situation.

4. Manage Communications and Interactions with Association Representatives

Communications with a franchisee association and its members require care. Franchisors should remain professional, consistent, and focused on the concerns raised. Characterizing association activity as disloyal or disruptive, threatening adverse consequences, or discouraging franchisees from communicating with one another may raise interference or retaliation concerns.

Franchisors should also consider whether communications are best directed to association representatives, individual franchisees, or the system as a whole. Working through designated representatives may facilitate dialogue, but does not require the franchisor to recognize the association as a formal negotiating body or authorize it to bind its members.

If an association is represented by counsel, the franchisor should involve its own franchise counsel to evaluate the association’s position, assess applicable contractual and statutory rights, and guide the response. Counsel-to-counsel communications can help ensure the franchisor’s position is appropriately framed. 

Franchisors should also document association communications, franchisee complaints, and related decisions. 

If enforcement action is subsequently taken against an association member for an independent contractual violation, documentation of the underlying violation and consistent enforcement practices may help demonstrate that the action was unrelated to protected association activity.

5. Address Legitimate Concerns While Preserving System Standards

Franchisee associations can provide valuable insight into operational challenges affecting multiple locations. When an association raises concerns shared by its members, franchisors should consider whether those concerns identify broader issues warranting attention.

Listening to an association’s concerns, however, does not require franchisors to accept every demand, negotiate every systemwide decision, or abandon established operating standards. Subject to applicable law and contractual limitations, franchisors generally retain the authority provided under their franchise agreements to protect brand consistency and implement systemwide initiatives.

Depending on the circumstances, an appropriate response may involve adjusting implementation timelines, providing additional training, improving communications, or explaining the rationale behind a particular requirement. In other situations, maintaining existing standards may be necessary to protect the brand and the franchise system. The objective is to take franchisee concerns seriously without compromising the franchisor’s legitimate authority to manage the system.

6. Establish a Consistent Approach to Franchisee Associations

Franchisors should consider establishing internal protocols for addressing franchisee associations and other forms of collective franchisee activity. These protocols should identify who is authorized to communicate with association representatives, how concerns are evaluated and escalated, when franchise counsel should be involved, and how relevant communications and decisions are documented.

Management, field representatives, and operations personnel who regularly interact with franchisees should understand the legal considerations involved. Franchisee organizing is not limited to formal associations; similar considerations may apply when franchisees communicate through informal groups, industry organizations, or social media.

For franchisors operating across multiple jurisdictions, internal practices should also account for differences in applicable state franchise relationship laws. Periodic consultation with franchise counsel can help ensure that the franchisor’s approach remains appropriate as legal requirements evolve.

CONCLUSION

Franchisee associations can give franchisees a collective voice and provide franchisors with insight into concerns affecting the system. How franchisors respond is critical. A thoughtful approach requires understanding the association’s objectives, recognizing applicable legal protections, and balancing franchisees’ rights with the franchisor’s contractual obligations and legitimate business interests.

Franchisors should involve experienced franchise counsel early, particularly when an association has retained counsel. Addressing these relationships with appropriate legal guidance can help prevent misunderstandings from escalating into disputes while protecting the franchisor’s ability to manage its brand and maintain system standards. Ultimately, constructive engagement, grounded in a clear understanding of the parties’ respective rights and responsibilities, can support a healthier and more sustainable franchise system.

How We Can Help

Kaufmann Gildin & Robbins LLP regularly represents franchisors of all sizes in negotiations with counsel representing franchisee associations. We facilitate constructive dialogue, address areas of disagreement, and work toward mutually acceptable resolutions before disputes escalate or tensions between the parties intensify. By serving as a direct point of contact for association counsel, we help keep discussions productive and focused on resolving issues amicably while minimizing friction between the parties.

We also advise franchisors on the state franchise relationship laws protecting franchisees’ right to associate, as well as the legal considerations that arise when franchisees organize to raise collective concerns. In these situations, we help franchisors navigate the applicable legal landscape, assess potential legal and business risks, and develop a strategic approach to addressing franchisee concerns while protecting the franchisor’s business interests and preserving the franchise relationship. For assistance, contact Michelle Murray-Bertrand at (212) 705-0855 or [email protected].

*Attorney advertising. © 2026 KAUFMANN GILDIN & ROBBINS • ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

Disclaimer: The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. You should consult an attorney for advice regarding your individual situation. We invite you to contact us and welcome your calls, letters and electronic mail. Contacting us does not create an attorney-client relationship. Please do not send any confidential information to us until such time as an attorney-client relationship has been established.

Subscribe to our blog: RSS feed • Visit our LinkedIn page